Shin Hae Chul slams So Nyeo Shi Dae boycott at 2008 Dream Concert

For people who want to know but refuse to step into the ANTI thread.

Veteran Korean singer Shin Hae Chul slammed the boycott of So Nyeo Shi Dae at the 2008 Dream Concert on 7th June during his SBS radio show on 10th June.


^ Tangera <3s this image.

Shin Hae Chul expressed

There’s a concert called Dream Concert in Korea. To put it bluntly, it’s just a concert where several thousands of fans comes in free of charge to listen to a few popular songs, that’s all. I went before once a few years back. There’s an ugly tradition at this concert and that is, staying silent on purpose when a specific group or singer is performing on stage. Simply put, it’s a tradition of bullying people.

He continued by saying

Heard that their target this year is So Nyeo Shi Dae. For me, it’s just a low-grade concert because of the low-class fans resulting in a low-class mass culture. The actions of those fans at Dream Concert reflects how low-class they are to the whole of Korea.

What do these fans think they can achieve by not clapping, turning their glowsticks off, etc? They don’t help the Korean music industry in any way nor are they able to stop it from advancing. If you like the performance, clap your hands. If you don’t like the performance, then don’t clap and that’s it. This bullying tradition will not be forgiven if it was played out in other countries. I hope that So Nyeo Shi Dae will not be hurt by the actions of these low-class fans.”

Source: Coolsmurf (thank you!)
==========================================
IGNORE ME. X.x

Spoiler:

whatever. cartel and all of us at the snsd anti-club aren't gonna change our minds and clap next time if we see them because they don't deserve cheers. he says in other countries it wont be forgiven? in america and other countries its our choice and is forgiven. he must have been brainwashed thinking of 9 girls licking lollipops...

=.=
this is lame...
it's a failure for a start if the fans stopped clapping and cheering for you.
seriously, that means the fans are not respecting you because you didn't!
it's a cycle....
btw...the silence treatment is good...i hope cartel would be in action again if this kind of concert happen.
*no offense*

LOW CLASS?!
shut your mouth before more things spill out that'll you'll regret, or would you like to be the next Bitchanny?

lowclass thats like 50,000 people who went to the dream concert. if he's talking about loww class he MUST have been talking about the snsd fan boys who acted like lowlife thugs.

Isn't he like contradicting himself or something? They don't like SNSD so they didn't clap, right? Hmmmm, btw he's 50 something years old right? This is surely a mature way to handle stuff, ajusshi.

Cartel is stopping the korean music industry from advancing because they didn't cheer for the 9 you- know- what ?

How old is this guy ? 10 ?

the 9 you-know-what is the THING that is stopping korean music industry from advancing.

Anti-fans are ridiculous.
Why can't people just like the bands they like? If you don't like a musician, don't buy their album, it's that simple.
Why should you go out of your way to hate on them. You just draw attention to them and bring them publicity, and the truth is ANY publicity is "good" publicity!
A lot of bad artists exist and make records, why should it be the fans or anti-fans business to tell them that they suck, their record sales will eventually reflect that!!
With so much hate in this world you would think that people would be able to unite with music, but here again we see how disgusting human nature is.
What are people trying to prove??
I feel disgusted knowing that fans of the same bands I like acted in such a manner or say and think such negative things.
The only good thing is that many of the fans are still young and will probably grow out of this phase, and for their sake, I hope so.
Hate who you hate, but expressing it in negative ways only brings conflict and that is something a fan or anti-fan of ANY band can agree, we do NOT need!

oh dear~ ........ low class fan??

^ Cassie's, ELFs, Triple S is NOT low grade fan - they are protevting and fighting back what's right!!!!!!!

If someone reads or hears what he says properly, they realise that he insulted pretty much everyone. Including SNSD, himself and the entire nation.

He makes himself out to look like an idiot, the best thing to do is not provoke any more fans, but instead he just cant help himself because of these low class people eh? Isnt it low class to attempt to bully listeners too? Didnt he also say that if anyone says anything he'll purposefully play SNSD songs for a year?

If he had any credibility left after all his previous antics, its gonna go when people who expect good music and a good show tune in to:

dooo do dooroodo doo
Kissing you baby!

Haechol ajoushi cant help but join in the fun can you?

What a joke. THIS elongates the situation more, when people who have nothing to do with it in the celbrity world encourage the fanboys who got violent.

Someone please speak out and condemn the violence instead, forget the silenceing for now, just condemn the violence.

I agree about how he is contradicting himself when he said if fans dont want to support, to not clap. I mean, thats exactly what the fans did! Not clap O_________O Grrr... grumble grumble.....


And I dont agree with "any publicity is good publicity". So, its alright to be humiliating other seniors who have accomplished more than what SNSD has ever done? Of-course simply saying that this is because they are young and such is wrong - what about other artists who debuted at a far younger age??

Its not simply 'uniting with music' . When you have about 9 girls running around, not only disrepecting their seniors, but the PD and other people as well, its sort of hard for fans to sit and listen and be all happy and giggly. And I cant believe Shin-dude is saying its the Catrels fault!

tell them to pull down their skirts to knee length, take out the silicon in their noses, sing an entire song without the help of their group and stop pretending to be innocent and cuute infront of the camera, THEN we'll talk about being a Musician.
these girls are nothing but a disgrace to koreans because mostly all of them had plastic surgery and prance around in short skirts showing their butts and who knows what else acting like 8 year olds when really most of them are at the age to be in college.

what?! low class...i think he is the low class one...is he also attracted to the mini skirts..

wow. Tangera. your comment said it all!! how can you call those tat did it low-class just for refusing to clap/cheer/and turn their lights on? they did what everyone's parents told them to do. "if you dont have anything good to say, then don't say anything". so they didnt cheer. they turned their lights of cuz havin it on would be cheering for them. its not like they booed them the whole perf. so how can they be low class?

i like how he called this a tradition too. how can being silent be a tradition when it JUST happened this yr. adn dotn u think somethings CLEALRY wrong with a group to have this done to them? i mean if they alreayd have this many ppl hatin on them and they havent even been in the industry for a yr. imagien the future.

it seems liek someone wants to get on snsd's nicer side. if you know wat i mean

Good, SNSD learn from this. Silent treatment is nothing compared at actually getting physically hurt. LSM should just end this group no one likes them orput them in more training. boo you.