Seo In Young accused for plagiarism after Seo Taiji and Lee Hyori

Post new topic   Reply to topic

View previous topic View next topic Go down

Seo In Young accused for plagiarism after Seo Taiji and Lee Hyori

Post by nata3105 on Thu Jul 24, 2008 9:46 am



Seo In Young is another comeback artiste amongst the list of Seo Taiji and Lee Hyori being accused of plagiarism.

Lee Hyori
who had her comeback on 16th July was accused of plagiarism for her album jacket and title song “U-Go-Girl” MV. [Netizens are becoming concerned over plagiarism in Hyori’s album jacket and MV] But those allegations were denied on the the part of Hyori’s company.

Being called the “Post Hyori” syndrome, Seo In Young is another artiste to be accused of plagiarism. She released her solo album “Elly is Cinderella” on 23rd July. One of her album jacket photos, featuring her with a black hat and 2 heart shapes drawn under her eyes, was said to have plagiarized one of Japanese model Coco Rocha’s pictorials. Also the ribbons-donning image and unique eyelashes in her teaser video were also said to have plagiarized the style of Japanese single Ayumi Hamazaki. Hence they had eliminated out those scenes off the full MV of Seo In Young’s title song “Cinderella”.

Seo In Young’s company had denied the allegations saying that the ribbons and eyelashes are common fashion items used by singers, ruling out any intentional plagiarism.



Also another artiste Seo Taiji, whose comeback was hailed as the “return of the king”, will be releasing his 8th album on 29th July. The first single cover off his 8th album was also said to have plagiarized Iceland band Sigur Ros‘ 1999 album ‘Agaestin Byrjun’ album cover. Both album covers have featured a picture of a fetus.

Seo Taiji’s company had revealed that, “Because the song “The First Sound” is a very important code for Seo Taiji’s comeback album, we have used the picture of the fetus for the album cover.

There has been a lot of talking about makeup, style, and concept plagiarism in the kpop scene recently. It has seemed that even the most trivial case of a use of certain concept will drive fans and netizens’ imagination wild, eventually causing a huge fuss out of the whole incident. This indeed is a form of burden and problem for singers and their companies.


Source: sookyeong.wordpress.com
***Life is a journey. Use it wisely and enjoy your time since it won't comeback to you again. ***

nata3105
Moderator
Moderator

Posts : 257
Joined : 16 Jan 2008
Age : 21
Location : Indonesia
Warning : 
0/100/100/10 (0/10)

Back to top Go down

Re: Seo In Young accused for plagiarism after Seo Taiji and Lee Hyori

Post by Cutie on Thu Jul 24, 2008 10:48 am

heheh, I was right about SIYand Anna Tsuchiya XD
Or wait. It said, "have plagiarized one of Japanese model Coco Rocha’s pictorials."

If thats Coco... what about Anna?? Or did I misread something here O.o Although SIY pic is closest to the first picture. *sigh*

Spoiler:


But little dissapointed at others -_-"
Although... being in trouble for eyelash problems.... eh...

Too many problems lately... Crying or Very sad

Seo Tai Ji should just get rid of the wings.
http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/anti-snsd/index.html

Cutie
Friends Of SYP!
Friends Of SYP!

Posts : 1532
Joined : 19 Jan 2008
Age : 16
Location : Back from Hiatus~!
Warning : 
0/100/100/10 (0/10)

Back to top Go down

Re: Seo In Young accused for plagiarism after Seo Taiji and Lee Hyori

Post by aznsaranghae on Thu Jul 24, 2008 12:33 pm

wow that's pretty crazy. so many artist have been under plagiarism lately. don't now what to say. but anyways, thank you for sharing.

credits: strawberrybj@SYP, thanx (^__^)

aznsaranghae
SYP Candle Queen
SYP Candle Queen

Posts : 655
Joined : 11 Feb 2008
Age : 18
Location : Arizona, USA
Warning : 
0/100/100/10 (0/10)

Back to top Go down

Re: Seo In Young accused for plagiarism after Seo Taiji and Lee Hyori

Post by toocutedoggy on Thu Jul 24, 2008 1:44 pm

hmmm, these days, it's hard for them to come up something original~

toocutedoggy
SYP SuperFan
SYP SuperFan

Posts : 1677
Joined : 18 Jan 2008
Location : Canada
Warning : 
0/100/100/10 (0/10)

Back to top Go down

Re: Seo In Young accused for plagiarism after Seo Taiji and Lee Hyori

Post by Sweet Pink on Thu Jul 24, 2008 3:23 pm

people shouldn't go randomly accusing singers and companies of plagiarism. It's a big concept and not anything they do is plagiarism

Sweet Pink
SYP Princess
SYP Princess

Posts : 210
Joined : 19 Jul 2008
Age : 20
Location : Dubai, United Arab Emirates...in Ma Pink Bubble
Warning : 
0/100/100/10 (0/10)

Back to top Go down

Re: Seo In Young accused for plagiarism after Seo Taiji and Lee Hyori

Post by medirin on Thu Jul 24, 2008 3:56 pm

i think netizens go to far with the plagiarism accusations. people don't have sole rights to a style >.< people can dress the way they want!

medirin
The Quiet Type
The Quiet Type

Posts : 22
Joined : 26 Feb 2008
Age : 19
Location : Bronx, New York, USA
Warning : 
0/100/100/10 (0/10)

Back to top Go down

Re: Seo In Young accused for plagiarism after Seo Taiji and Lee Hyori

Post by dragonninja598000 on Thu Jul 24, 2008 8:26 pm

iono some of this is stupid. most of it is mainly perspective. what some call copyright infringement some call a remix. which technically they can sue for.


Last edited by dragonninja598000 on Thu Jul 24, 2008 11:13 pm; edited 1 time in total

dragonninja598000
SYP Knight
SYP Knight

Posts : 811
Joined : 18 Jan 2008
Warning : 
1/101/101/101/10 (1/10)

Back to top Go down

Re: Seo In Young accused for plagiarism after Seo Taiji and Lee Hyori

Post by steph on Thu Jul 24, 2008 8:53 pm

haha..i like wat they call post hyori syndrome..
just realise dat whenever there is a comeback, the first thing they mention is never bout da album but is plagiarism..
shouldnt they focus more on the music rather then other things??is getting lame to always bring up plagiarism issue

steph
SYP Princess
SYP Princess

Posts : 120
Joined : 27 Jun 2008
Location : far far away
Warning : 
0/100/100/10 (0/10)

Back to top Go down

Re: Seo In Young accused for plagiarism after Seo Taiji and Lee Hyori

Post by sbambit on Fri Jul 25, 2008 12:55 am

designers and artists are inspired by other people and things. just because someone uses fake eyelashes doesn't mean another person can't do it. i dont have a problem with In Young or any artist for that matter being inspired by another person and using their concepts...unless those concepts and ideas are copyrighted.

i think netizens are retarded for claiming everything is plagarism. ultimately one could argue that the person who came up with Coco Rocha's pictorial concept was "plagarizing" a clown since the shapes-makeup had a circusy-vibe to it.

everything is plagarism with netizens...and most of it cannot even be argued or proved to be legitimate. its so frustrating.

sbambit
SYP Princess
SYP Princess

Posts : 68
Joined : 18 Jan 2008
Warning : 
0/100/100/10 (0/10)

Back to top Go down

Re: Seo In Young accused for plagiarism after Seo Taiji and Lee Hyori

Post by sylph8 on Tue Jul 29, 2008 4:55 pm

i agree with sbambit
why do netizens always accuse singers of plagarism
it's so stupid

sylph8
The Quiet Type
The Quiet Type

Posts : 23
Joined : 29 Jul 2008
Location : somewhere over the rainbow
Warning : 
0/100/100/10 (0/10)

Back to top Go down

View previous topic View next topic Back to top


Permissions of this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum